Mobile Guides6 min read

iD Mobile vs giffgaff (November 2026): Three or O2, Which Cheap SIM Wins?

iD Mobile vs giffgaff: Three vs O2 coverage, credit checks, data rollover, roaming and contract options compared, with links to live SIM deals.

Switch Editorial Team

Written by Switch Editorial Team

Share with
Woman with a purple tote at a market under a church spire

iD Mobile or giffgaff: which cheap SIM is better? It mostly comes down to which network works where you live. iD Mobile runs on Three’s network and giffgaff runs on O2’s, so the same phone can get a strong signal on one and a weak one on the other. Beyond coverage, the biggest practical difference is the credit check: iD’s 12-month and 24-month plans include one, while giffgaff says its 18-month SIM plans do not. iD adds free data rollover and roaming in 50 destinations; giffgaff lets you change plan every month and has a pay as you go option. Prices on both change often, so compare today’s plans on our iD Mobile SIM-only deals and giffgaff SIM-only deals pages before you choose.

Last updated: 21 November 2026. Plan features are taken from iD Mobile’s and giffgaff’s own websites, as set out in our iD Mobile review (checked 18 November 2026) and giffgaff review (checked 17 November 2026). We do not quote prices on this page because they change week to week: the deal pages linked above show live prices. Check the plan page before you pay, because allowances and terms can change.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It does not change the price you pay.

iD Mobile vs giffgaff at a glance

iD Mobile

giffgaff

Host network

Three

O2

Owned by

Currys (iD Mobile is a trading name of Currys Group Limited)

Virgin Media O2

Plan types

1-month rolling plans, plus 12-month and 24-month plans

18-month plans, monthly rolling plans and pay as you go (goodybags)

Credit check

Yes on 12-month and 24-month plans

None on its 18-month SIM plans, according to giffgaff

5G

Included on Three’s 5G network

Included at no extra cost on 5G phones in 5G areas

Unused data

Data rollover: unused data lasts one extra month and is used first

No rollover; you can move up or down a plan each month instead

Roaming

Roaming in 50 destinations, with a 30GB fair use limit

EU roaming included up to 5GB

Live prices

See live iD Mobile SIM deals

See live giffgaff SIM deals

Our iD Mobile review and giffgaff review go through each network’s plans in more detail.

See every plan side by side: today's iD Mobile SIM-only deals and today's giffgaff SIM-only deals.

Coverage: Three vs O2

Because neither brand owns its own masts, the network underneath is what decides call quality and data speed where you are. iD uses Three’s network (Three is now part of VodafoneThree) and giffgaff uses O2’s. Signal on both can vary from one street to the next, and indoors can be different again.

The most reliable way to choose is to check your home postcode, your work postcode and anywhere else you spend a lot of time. Ofcom’s free mobile coverage checker shows predicted coverage for each network, and both Three and O2 publish their own coverage maps. If friends or family already use one of the two networks, ask how the signal is in the places you go. If you are unsure, a rolling plan on either brand lets you try it for a month without being tied in.

Contracts, credit checks and flexibility

The two brands take different approaches to commitment.

  • iD Mobile sells 1-month rolling plans as well as 12-month and 24-month plans. The fixed-term plans include a credit check. iD also says its SIM-only plans have no annual price rises (a commitment it renewed in January 2026); confirm this in the plan terms at checkout.

  • giffgaff sells 18-month plans, monthly rolling plans and pay as you go goodybags. giffgaff says its 18-month SIM plans have no credit check, and you can change to a bigger or smaller plan each month. Its rolling plans usually cost more than its 18-month plans for the same data.

If you have a thin or poor credit history, giffgaff’s 18-month plans or either brand’s rolling plans are the simpler route. If you want the lowest fixed price for a year or two and are happy with a credit check, compare iD’s 12-month and 24-month plans with giffgaff’s 18-month plans on a total-cost basis, not just the monthly figure.

Data extras and roaming

iD’s data rollover means unused data from one month carries into the next and is used first, which suits people whose usage goes up and down. iD also includes roaming in 50 destinations, subject to a 30GB fair use limit, which is worth having if you travel outside Europe.

giffgaff includes EU roaming up to 5GB. For a week or two in Europe that is often enough; for longer trips or heavier use, check the limit against your plan before you travel.

Both brands include unlimited UK calls and texts on their pay monthly SIM plans. Check each plan page for its current roaming list and any limits, as these can change.

Customer service

giffgaff’s support is mostly online: help articles, its member community and messaging rather than a traditional phone line. iD Mobile is run by Currys. If being able to phone a call centre matters to you, check each brand’s current contact options before you switch.

Who should pick iD Mobile, and who should pick giffgaff?

iD Mobile may suit you if:

  • Three’s signal is good where you live and work.

  • You want data rollover, or roaming beyond Europe.

  • You are happy with a credit check in return for a fixed 12-month or 24-month plan.

giffgaff may suit you if:

  • O2’s signal is better where you spend your time.

  • You want to avoid a credit check, or keep the option of pay as you go.

  • You like being able to change plan every month.

Still not sure? Compare both against other cheap networks in our Lebara vs giffgaff and VOXI vs giffgaff guides, or browse all SIM-only deals.

How to switch between iD Mobile and giffgaff

  1. Check coverage at your postcode for the network you are moving to.

  2. Get your PAC code if you want to keep your number: text PAC to 65075 from your current phone. To leave without keeping your number, text STAC to 75075. Both are free, and the reply tells you about any charges for leaving early.

  3. Order your new SIM or eSIM and enter the PAC code during checkout or in your new account.

  4. Wait for the switch. Ofcom’s rules say your number should normally move within one working day. Your old plan ends when the number moves.

FAQ

Is iD Mobile better than giffgaff?

Neither is better for everyone. iD Mobile runs on Three and adds data rollover and roaming in 50 destinations; giffgaff runs on O2 and has no credit check on its 18-month SIM plans. The better choice is usually the one whose network gives you a good signal at home and work. Compare live prices on our iD Mobile and giffgaff SIM deal pages.

Which networks do iD Mobile and giffgaff use?

iD Mobile uses Three’s network. giffgaff uses O2’s network and is owned by Virgin Media O2. Coverage, speed and indoor signal come from those host networks.

Do iD Mobile and giffgaff do a credit check?

iD Mobile’s 12-month and 24-month plans include a credit check. giffgaff says its 18-month SIM plans have no credit check, and its pay as you go goodybags do not need one either.

Can I keep my number if I switch between iD Mobile and giffgaff?

Yes. Text PAC to 65075 from your current phone to get a free PAC code, then give it to your new provider when you order. Ofcom’s rules say the number should normally move within one working day.

Which is cheaper, iD Mobile or giffgaff?

It depends on how much data you need and how long a contract you want, and both brands change their prices often. Our iD Mobile and giffgaff SIM-only deal pages list live plans side by side with monthly prices and contract lengths, so you can compare the total cost before you choose.

Ready to compare?

Compare SIM deals